Key Takeaways:
- 82 years ago, a Japanese submarine sank the SS Tilawa, carrying 2,364 bars of silver.
- In 2017, the silver was recovered, leading to legal battles over ownership.
- Argentum Exploration Ltd, owned by Sir Paul Marshall, was involved in the legal proceedings.
- The UK Supreme Court allowed South Africa’s appeal regarding ownership of the silver.
- The tragic incident involving the SS Tilawa claimed the lives of 280 passengers.
The Tycoon and the Treasure Hunter
In 1942, the SS Tilawa was hit by two torpedoes from a Japanese submarine, sinking the ship and valuable cargo in the Indian Ocean. Fast forward to 2017, the silver bars were recovered, sparking a legal battle over ownership between Argentum Exploration Ltd and the South African government.
Silver Worth R792-million
Argentum initially attempted to claim ownership of the recovered silver, valued at approximately R792 million. However, the UK Supreme Court ruled in favor of South Africa’s appeal, recognizing the government as the rightful owner of the salvaged silver.
Coins for South Africa
The silver bars destined for Durban were intended for the production of coins for both South Africa and Egypt. Unfortunately, the SS Tilawa tragedy prevented the delivery of the cargo, leading to a lengthy legal battle over ownership many years later.
Torpedoed Ocean Liner
The sinking of the SS Tilawa was a devastating event that claimed the lives of 280 passengers, leaving survivors with harrowing tales of panic and tragedy. The recovery of the silver bars from the seabed in 2017 reignited interest in the historical incident.
‘Finders Keepers’ Attempt
Despite initial attempts by Argentum to claim ownership of the salvaged silver, the company eventually acknowledged South Africa’s rights to the valuable cargo. Legal battles ensued over salvage claims, highlighting the complexities of maritime law in such cases.
Settlement
After years of legal proceedings, a settlement was reached in April 2024 regarding the ownership of the recovered silver. The UK Supreme Court decision favored South Africa’s appeal, solidifying the government’s ownership of the historical treasure.
Frequently Asked Questions:
1. Who owned the silver recovered from the SS Tilawa?
The UK Supreme Court ruled in favor of the South African government, recognizing them as the rightful owner of the silver.
2. What was the intended purpose of the silver bars on board the SS Tilawa?
The silver bars were procured for the production of coins for both South Africa and Egypt, serving both sovereign and commercial purposes.
3. What legal battles ensued over the ownership of the salvaged silver?
Argentum Exploration Ltd, owned by Sir Paul Marshall, attempted to claim ownership of the silver but eventually conceded to South Africa’s rights to the valuable cargo.

Leave a Reply